$28.5M Melbourne Brain Injury Verdict: Landmark Florida TBI Case
A computer engineer stopped to help at a roadside accident and was violently assaulted, leaving him with a permanent traumatic brain injury and $28.5 million in damages.
AS SEEN ON:
⏱︎ 3 Decades Serving Melbourne
$28.5M Melbourne Brain Injury Verdict: Landmark Florida TBI Case
A computer engineer stopped to help at a roadside accident and was violently assaulted, leaving him with a permanent traumatic brain injury and $28.5 million in damages.
AS SEEN ON:
⏱︎ 35 Years Serving Melbourne, FL | 🤝 No Fee Unless We Win
Record-Setting Verdict for Catastrophic Neurological Damage
On an October morning in 2005, a 43-year-old computer engineer pulled over to help at a minor traffic accident.
He never imagined his Good Samaritan act would result in a brutal, unprovoked assault, leaving him with a permanent traumatic brain injury.
The General Sales Manager of a car dealership violently head-butted him, knocking him unconscious. The attack continued as he lay defenseless on the ground.
Our client developed dystonia, a neurological disorder causing involuntary muscle contractions, severe daily pain, and cognitive difficulties. He went from a highly skilled professional with top-secret military clearance to requiring full-time care from his wife and three children.
The defense fought hard—contesting liability, causation, and damages at every turn. They argued the attacker wasn't acting within the scope of employment and tried to attribute our client's condition to pre-existing issues.
We brought in multiple treating physicians, neurologists, and a grief expert to help the jury understand the profound loss this family experienced.
The Brevard County jury apportioned 60% fault to the attacker, 30% to the dealership, and 10% to the parent company, holding both corporations vicariously liable.
The $28.5 million verdict covered past and future medical expenses, lost earnings, pain and suffering, and loss of consortium for his wife and children.
This case demonstrated how traumatic brain injuries ripple through entire families, and how thorough preparation with the right medical experts can make the difference in catastrophic injury cases.
Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Every case is different, and each client's case must be evaluated and handled on its own merits. The facts and circumstances of your case may differ from the matters in which results have been provided.
Decades of Brain Injury Advocacy
Traumatic brain injury cases demand expert medical testimony to prove causation and demonstrate the full scope of physical, cognitive, and emotional harm.
I've seen insurance companies challenge even the most obvious brain injuries, questioning whether a violent assault truly caused lasting damage. In this case, we assembled a powerhouse team of experts who walked the jury through every diagnostic test, every cognitive deficit, every lost capability. The defense tried to blame pre-existing conditions, but our experts made causation undeniable. That medical foundation—combined with testimony about the family's transformation into full-time caregivers—was what turned a contested liability case into a record verdict.
— Douglas R. Beam
How We Build Brain Injury Cases Step-by-Step
Learn how the team at Douglas R. Beam, P.A. builds compelling brain injury cases to get real wins for victims.
Our team works with neurologists, neuropsychologists, and imaging specialists to establish causation and document every aspect of the injury. Medical evidence—including diagnostic imaging, treatment records, and neurological testing—forms the foundation of these claims. In this case, multiple treating physicians confirmed the assault caused the client's condition, while detailed testimony explained his cognitive decline, physical limitations, and daily care needs to the jury.
We coordinate a team of expert witnesses—including neurologists, neuropsychologists, life care planners, economic analysts, and grief experts—to establish the causes, consequences, and future costs of brain injury. Each expert provides a unique perspective: causation, prognosis, care requirements, economic impact, and family burden. Their testimonies are integral in translating complex medical realities into compelling courtroom evidence.
Advanced diagnostic imaging, such as CT, MRI, and functional neuroimaging, often plays a critical role in confirming and illustrating traumatic brain injuries. We ensure all relevant scans are interpreted by recognized specialists and explained in plain terms to judges and juries. These visuals can powerfully demonstrate hidden damage and validate symptoms that might otherwise be contested by defense teams.
Life care planning is essential to ensure clients with catastrophic brain injuries receive full compensation for current and future needs. Our chosen life care planners collaborate with treating doctors, occupational therapists, and family to map out a detailed care plan. The resulting report calculates the cost of medical treatment, therapy, adaptive equipment, and in-home assistance for the client's lifetime, depending on their specific circumstances.
Our economic experts meticulously analyze both past and projected financial losses—factoring in lost earning capacity, household contributions, medical care, and inflation. This analysis becomes a cornerstone of evidence, translating the profound impact of brain injuries into tangible figures for the jury and helping ensure families receive resources to support long-term recovery.
Brain Injury Verdict Questions Answered Here
Common questions about brain injury verdicts, compensation, and legal accountability—answered by attorneys with decades of experience in catastrophic injury litigation.
Brain injury settlement amounts in Florida vary widely based on medical costs, lost income, permanence of impairment, and quality of life impact. In cases like this one, where injuries were catastrophic and lifelong, the jury awarded $28.5 million. Many settlements range from thousands to millions depending on circumstances. Insurance coverage, available assets, and specific damages all play a role. Consulting an experienced attorney helps ensure your claim is properly valued.
Causation in traumatic brain injury cases typically relies on diagnostic imaging (MRI, CT scans), documented medical symptoms, neuropsychological testing, and expert testimony from neurologists. The connection between the incident and injury must be clearly demonstrated, particularly when defense teams argue alternative causes. In cases like this one involving employer assault, thorough evidence becomes even more critical. The stronger your medical documentation and expert support, the better positioned your case will be.
Yes, in many cases. Under Florida law, employers can be held responsible through vicarious liability when an employee commits assault during work or in connection with company interests. Courts examine the location, employment relationship, and whether the action related to business. In this case, both the dealership and parent company shared liability for their manager's conduct. Each situation depends on specific facts, but this verdict demonstrated how corporate accountability can extend to employee actions. See our negligent security cases for more examples.
A catastrophic brain injury case typically involves investigation, medical evaluation, evidence collection, expert consultations, and liability analysis. If settlement negotiations don't succeed, your attorney presents detailed proof of damages and responsibility at trial. These cases often require months or years to develop fully. Each step matters. Working with an experienced brain injury attorney in Melbourne is crucial for navigating this complex process and achieving fair compensation.
Family members may claim loss of consortium damages in traumatic brain injury cases—compensating for lost companionship, affection, support, and shared activities. Catastrophic injuries often change family dynamics forever. In this case, we presented testimony from a grief expert to help the jury understand the profound loss experienced by the spouse and children, who became full-time caregivers overnight.
Lost earning capacity is calculated by comparing your pre-injury employment history, skills, and projected future income to your post-injury abilities. Expert economists and vocational analysts assess how cognitive or physical limitations affect your ability to work. In cases involving severe brain injuries, these future losses often represent a substantial portion of total damages, particularly when clients can no longer perform specialized work.
Typically, neurologists, neuropsychologists, life care planners, economists, and sometimes grief experts testify in brain injury cases. Each provides specialized insight: medical causation, prognosis, care needs, financial impact, and emotional harm to the family. Their combined testimony helps courts understand both the science and the profound human cost of traumatic brain injuries.
Dystonia is a neurological movement disorder causing involuntary muscle contractions, often resulting in severe pain and impaired function. When linked to traumatic brain injury—as in this case—it typically develops from damage to brain regions controlling movement. Medical experts establish this connection through diagnostic imaging, clinical evaluation, and documented symptom onset following trauma.
In cases like this one, trial often spans several years. Our client's journey took nearly seven years from the October 2005 incident to the 2012 verdict. Complex brain injury cases typically require extensive medical documentation, expert testimony, and thorough investigation to establish causation and damages. When liability is disputed and corporate entities are involved, the timeline can extend as defense teams employ various strategies to minimize responsibility.
Typically, Florida's statute of limitations for personal injury is two years from the date of injury. However, circumstances like delayed diagnosis or involved parties can affect this timeline. It's crucial to consult an attorney promptly. Waiting too long can forfeit your right to compensation entirely, regardless of how strong your case might be.
Big Results. Little Stress.
This landmark verdict reflects decades of dedicated advocacy and deep experience with catastrophic brain injuries. We've built our reputation through meticulous preparation, collaboration with leading medical experts, and unwavering commitment to families facing devastating losses. Our track record speaks to the results possible when experience meets determination.